Play a game and make a defensive switch with the catcher. Sub a bench player in for the catcher and the he will catch with his hand, not his glove.
A Great Team
First do a season. Then turn force trades on and when you start your season you can get any player from any team even if you go over your salary cap.
Game Play Tip
Get the best players in the league and play a season for 52 games and and play for 3 innings and do classic mode on batting and pitching and at the start you will put the difficulty at rookie and the computer will go real easy.